The Meaning Of The Word Proof Essay - 1842 Words

Foreman address the meaning of the word â€Å"proof† in the context of questions concerning God’s existence or non-existence. He specifies that in this context, â€Å"proof† does not mean as it does in its more natural context, mathematics, a demonstration that within the agreed-on axioms follows necessarily, but rather something else, and nevertheless of value. A â€Å"proof† of God, says Foreman, are defeasible, yet have not (yet) been defeated. They are valuable because they offer the best explanation for what we observe in nature. McCloskey does not share Foreman’s sense of â€Å"proof.† His line of thought runs as follows: since the â€Å"proofs† of God’s existence cannot be definitively established – they are defeasible, unlike mathematical proofs – they should be abandoned. This seems like a totalitarian gesture, since we know that multiple, often paradoxical senses, can run through the same signifier, in this case, â€Å"proof,† yet to McCloskey, because the sense of â€Å"proof† that he demands is not pertinent in this context, the word is mistaken, and therefore the arguments and whatever values they may share ought to be abandoned. This is not a strong position, but rather reflective of a miserly relationship to words’ multiple senses. McCloskey nevertheless attends to specific claims presented in each of the more popular proofs for God’s existence. Regarding the Cosmological Proof, he says, the existence of the world does not entitle one to hold that, since the world consists of anShow MoreRelatedHw 1-Logic Essay1468 Words   |  6 Pagesimmediately restated, nearly word for word. ix. Because the conclusion is supported by a chain of reasoning involving a premise that restates or presupposes the conclusion, __________________.) (If the conclusion is merely presupposed and not restated, write which explicit premise presupposes it: __________________.) x. Because the premises are relevant only if an implicit premise, _________________, is accepted. But this premise is the very idea most in need of proof. It is especiallyRead MoreOthello, By William Shakespeare923 Words   |  4 Pagesthat what they see automatically fits into the mental mold they have already created, therefore confirming their suspicions. Iago makes use of a deadly weapon, his words, to mislead characters into misinterpreting what they see. The characters in Othello are unable to recognize the hidden meaning of words often missing the deeper meaning and accepting them at face value. This is evident in several passages, such as Cassio’s fight with Montano and when Iago and Cassio speak about Bianca. Othello believesRead MoreThe Rabbit Proof Fence, Remembering Babylon, And Puddn1391 Words   |  6 PagesFollow the Rabbit Proof Fence, Remembering Babylon, and Puddn’head Wilson all contain numerous references to borders of various kinds, both literal and figurative. Focusing on two of the above texts, answer the following question: what do these borders represent? The ideas of borders, boundaries and border crossings are increasingly employed in a metaphorical sense that does not always refer to the physical border. These borders are progressively used to represent social and cultural boundaries.Read MoreThe Method Of Development : William Shakespeare s Othello1359 Words   |  6 Pages Stereotyping and Gender inequality. Throughout the play, Shakespeare elaborates on these terms. Transition word: The first Introductory paragraph: Postcolonial terms related to the play that convey inequality between everyone is Discrimination. Transition word: An example would be Point #1: when Iago discriminated Othello because he was black. Iago wakes up Brabantio by saying, Proof: Even now, now, very now, an old black ram / Is tupping your white ewe. Arise, arise! / Awake the snorting citizensRead MoreQuiz on Philosophy and Reasoning859 Words   |  3 Pagesthe ways you should look for the reasons used to support an argument? Panning for gold is the way the authors claim readers can look for the reasons being used to support an argument. This involves asking critical questions, seeking underlying meanings, and motives for why the person writes. For example, readers should ask why the writer is trying to persuade to discover the hidden motives. The person should evaluate the argument for textual or factual evidence. The person should form his or herRead MoreJohn Stuart Mill s Argument That Happiness Is The Only Intrinsic Good1354 Words   |  6 PagesIn this essay I am going to write about John Stuart Mill’s argument that happiness is the only intrinsic good. Mill’s proof focuses on defending utilitarianism, one of the most prominent works in moral philosophy and most prominent form of consequentialism as proposed by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Mill defines the theory and provides his responses to common misconceptions people have surrounding it. Utility, the Greatest Happiness Prin ciple, states that actions are right in that they generallyRead MoreAugustine s Ontological Proof For The Existence Of God1456 Words   |  6 PagesAugustine’s Ideo-Ontological proof for the existence of god. However, as with most things of a philosophical nature, there is no simple right or wrong, A or B reading of the Ideo-Ontological proof. Despite any possible contention that may occur over the interpretations of the Ideo-Ontological proof, there is no doubt that the proof contributed greatly towards the development of western philosophy, as started by Plato centuries prior. The primary concept behind the Ideo-Ontological proof is that god is a thinkerRead MoreEssay on Palace of Mirrors by Margaret Peterson Haddix831 Words   |  4 Pagesprincess. *Meaning~ Denotation for the word Beggars is they live by begging and the connotation for the word is homeless with nothing to eat or drink. The word beggars is important in this story because without the beggars of their city Cecilia wouldn’t of been able to act like one , on page 217-218 where it quotes â€Å"Okay,so I look terrible. So what? Wait a minute-can I use that?†. Which means that if there weren’t any beggars she couldn’t use that disguise. Denotation for the word harp is a musicalRead MoreDetermining if Trademarks are Distintive1538 Words   |  6 Pagesa frozen vegetable package â€Å"leaf† design was not believed to be an â€Å"obvious, certain, different† means of identifying â€Å"Seabrook Farms.† Instead, the court decided that the design was a decorative panel that served the purpose of background for the word port of the trademark. Bar-Well Foods was able to prove that Sea brook’s design was not uncommon in the frozen food market. The Seabrook test finds itself of great utility because it shows the importance of market context. Under this court will determineRead MoreAn Examination Into The Respective Proofs Of St. Aquinas1288 Words   |  6 Pagesthe Respective Proofs of St. Anselm and St. Aquinas During the Medieval Period, philosophers shifted their focus primarily to proving the existence of God, as well as other religious tenets. Two Saints of the Catholic Church, St. Anselm and St. Thomas Aquinas, developed their own respective proofs for the existence of God. These proofs have gained fame over the subsequent centuries and still face debate and comparison today. Although both St. Anselm and St. Thomas Aquinas offer proofs for the existence